This was submitted and published as a “Close to Home” in the Press Democrat.
California’s Affirmatively Furthering Fair Housing law says local housing policy must include meaningful actions to replace “segregated living patterns with truly integrated and balanced living patterns,” and jurisdictions are prohibited from taking any action that is “materially inconsistent with its obligation to affirmatively further fair housing.”
Historians Isabel Wilkerson and Richard Rothstein have many works that provide compelling evidence of systemic segregation throughout the U.S., and this includes the city of Sonoma.
The NAACP Santa Rosa-Sonoma County Branch is understandably concerned that the fair housing law is implemented because of an obvious current history of discrimination against community members. The need for the law, including the replacement of segregated living patterns, comes from a history of U.S. government-backed segregation, redlining and restrictive covenants.
California’s Restrictive Covenant Modification law has recently been implemented by the Sonoma County Recorder’s Office to address this history of segregation by identifying and expunging restrictive covenants from property deeds. Those wishing to see if their property has restrictive covenants can also make a formal request at the Recorder’s Office.
A recent records request showed that a number of past development tracts on Sonoma’s east side had restrictive covenants. For example, in the Frugoli Tract, “No persons of any race other than Caucasian shall use or occupy any building or any lot, except that this covenant shall not prevent occupancy by domestic servants of a different race domiciled with an owner or tenant.”
The NAACP Santa Rosa-Sonoma County Branch is currently working with the Recorder’s Office to find more maps.
In the first draft of the most recent Sonoma housing element, the DeNovo Planning Group, which is also doing the city’s general plan update, said “there are no known historic patterns of segregation by race and ethnicity, persons with disabilities, familial status, age or income.” This was retracted after overwhelming evidence presented by the public showed otherwise. Still, Sonoma leaders show a deep reticence to openly address the city’s history of segregation or to even admit that this is and was a problem. We feel that meaningful action on the state’s Affirmatively Furthering Fair Housing law is stifled by such a determined lack of attention.
Addressing segregation as a current issue upon which Sonoma’s overwhelming whiteness is based, is frequently met by stonewalling and denial. A whole new covert architecture for the justification of segregation has evolved, centering on coded phrases such as “the protection and preservation of low-density neighborhood character.”
Additionally, pertaining to the new emphasis on fire evacuation and maintaining low-density land use, California’s Housing and Community Development agency says, “Addressing disaster risk is not a justification for furthering segregation, and policies that seek to address this risk should include strategies that mitigate the risk of displacement and exclusion.”
The city of Sonoma is now cooperating on a public records request. The city clerk says there are few historic records in its current holdings. Where did the old records go?
In the past, the city gave some of its historical records to the Sonoma Valley Historical Society; however, the scope and quantity is unknown. Local historians know incredible detail about past events here, but segregation appears to be a pertinent unknown.
Santa Rosa-Sonoma County NAACP asks for a full and impartial inventory of old city records at the society.
Sonoma, like other suburban locations in the U.S., has a mythology to uphold. Current tourism boosting centers on a partial story about how great it all is. Since there appears to be no problems now, the assumption goes that there must not be any.
How can segregated living patterns be addressed and replaced if they are not admitted?
###





